Sidelined by sexism
All school-sponsored sports should be supported, regardless of gender
Originally published in May 2013 print issue.
“Behind every great man is a great Senior Girl.”
That was the Senior Girls’ slogan for the 2010 football season.
Harmless, right? The football player goes out and does the dirty work on the field while his doting female attendants stay back in the kitchen, baking and making signs for him with markers and butcher paper. That’s the way it’s “supposed” to be. And the female athletes? Yeah, nobody really cares about them. Everybody knows the only sports worth recognizing are played by men.
Take a look around the Commons. The center is completely blanketed with signs celebrating the male athletes made by “their” girls. They’re impossible to totally ignore, and many of them hang there long after the sport seasons have ended — we may be otherwise tempted to forget how central the focus is on boys athletics at this school.
Go stand on the W and look up. You’ll see gaudy handwritten signs reading “Brandon’s gonna tame those Tigers” or “Michael mashes Cavs.” But do you see any sign left up for the girls soccer team on its dominant run to the State semifinals this (spring 2013) season? How about some acknowledgment of the softball team’s impressive regular season? The girls teams have been quietly outperforming the boys for years, but you’d never know it.
Fun fact: of the 30 State Championships won at Westlake in gender-specific sports, girls teams have accounted for 20 of them. But that doesn’t matter, because we’re seemingly stuck in the pre-Title IX days here, when girls were only allowed to play 3-on-3 half court basketball. The pedestal the boy athletes are placed on exaggerates how little attention the girl athletes receive.
The mixed-gender sports are also given the cold shoulder. Who is making signs for the swim team? When was the last time someone made cookies for tennis? Have the perennial State-contending golf teams ever been properly recognized? The student body doesn’t even pretend to care about these activities, and since they’re not male-dominated, no outside group dares to adopt or support any of them.
Although it was started exclusively for the football team, similar volunteering outlets to the Senior Girls have expanded to reach soccer, basketball, lacrosse, baseball and rugby. They put countless hours into baking cookies and cake balls for “their” boys before their big games. Granted, nobody is forced into being a Senior Girl, Soccer Sweetie, Courtside Cutie, Stick Chick, Bleacher Babe or Rugger Hugger, but the system is an excellent reflection of an unwritten gender hierarchy that too many still accept as the norm. Not only is the concept extremely sexist, but it reinforces the idea that the men are meant to go out and show their strength while the “weak and feeble” girls watch from the sidelines and provide moral support.
There’s a simple solution to this problem that the Hyline and the band have already adopted. Every year, they bring breakfast for each other on the dates of their major competitions. Although nobody is given individualized attention, both organizations feel supported. If, for instance, other organizations like volleyball and wrestling teamed up to support each other by attending matches and exchanging gifts, all sports would feel equally valued. This mutual appreciation doesn’t have to be as time-consuming as the support groups already in place, and it would be a step in the right direction towards building the confidence of all teams, sports and otherwise, while dropping the stereotype that Westlake has been accepting for years.
Long-standing traditions can sometimes be hard to pull away from, but it’s high time that we take a step back and look at the blatant sexism that’s been festering under our noses. It’s 2013. Our society has grown increasingly non-gender exclusive, and there’s no reason that Westlake should not follow suit.
Nick Antone • Oct 6, 2013 at 9:19 pm
Awesome article! Texas must be rough lol
Anonymous • Sep 24, 2013 at 9:52 pm
While I kind of understand the point of the article, it bothers me how focused it is on sports. They mention that girls sports recieve n appreciation, what about non-athletic activities? Last year model UN won several awards at the state level and no one cared. Also last year two westlake robotics teams went to world championship, and both finished incredibly well. It really bothers me that if football even gets close to state you’ll never hear the end of it. But an activity that actually benefits students goes to the worldchampionship. No who would care about that.
Anonymous • Sep 23, 2013 at 3:10 pm
if all the author is trying to do is call for a similar system for girls sports, and more respect for girls sports, then by all means I support the author. But if this article was meant as an attack on football, it is misguided. I don’t agree with the senior girls system, but it is a tradition that doesn’t have much opposition against it, so it will stay unless so something drastic occurs in this football school. This is a good article, but it doesn’t seem to have a focused target.
Eugene Miravete • Sep 23, 2013 at 3:09 pm
While your article highlights some iteresting points, i have to disagree with you completely. Like Zach said, everyone has full rights to support their athletes, be they male or female. However, the problem may not be that our society, or at least our westalke high school environment, is sexist, but that in reality people choose to support the sports they like. At the highschool level, the only sport that turns a profit for the school, actually the only club, is westlake highschool football. Most of that money is taken from the football team(s) and given to other clubs. This trend continues well into college, with basketball being break-even then. The reason for this is the amount of interest in the comunity. How many people, beyond family, attend swimming meets, or golf tournaments. Dont get me wrong, those athletes work like crazy and their effort is commendable, but football attracts practically the entire student body as well as most of the community as fans, making it a bit of a big deal. And when it comes down to being sexist, no one is stopping girls from joining the football team. More than one girl has played football at the middle school level, and i do believe it was Anderson high school who had girls on their freshman team. If girls chose to boycott the tradition of senior girls and baking for football players they have every right to, they also have every right to continue that tradition. Should somoene want to start a tradition of baking and supporting all athletes, be my guest. And instead of taking the time to write and publish an article that insults a decades long tradition of thanks for some athletes, why dont you support some of the groups of athletes that you consider underapreciated. And, just by the way, that hyline and band tradition does exist among other sports groups, just saying.
Cassy • Sep 22, 2013 at 12:29 pm
The article is well written, timely and completely relevant. The accomplishment of female athletes at this school are completely over looked by the community and the student body as a whole. Also, football gets more attention than all of the other sports combined. The funny thing is that football is the only sport that doesn’t cut, so only a handful of players are actually relevant to the team. In all of the other sports, only the BEST athletes make the team. Football creates a culture of entitlement for boys who may not really have earned the right to all of the accolades. Just one more thing…Zach…you should probably refrain from commenting on any forums until you learn how to use proper grammar and how to spell. Your poorly written response is an embarrassment to the Eanes community.
Eugene Miravete • Sep 24, 2013 at 1:58 pm
Like i mentioned in my reply, a grand issue with sports is the number of fans, football may give its members an aura of entitlement, but it must also be the amount of fans that football atracts. Our footbal team has thousands of fans, the rest of sports just dont have that kind of culture or fanbase. The fact that it can do this witout cutting should be considered an achievement, considering how the coaches go out of their way to train athletes that are not considered their best. It may seem unfair that football gets more attention, but if people dont chose, and im talking the entire westlake community here, to support a sport, then try and rally support for other sports, but dont force recognition to athletes who a great deal of students and members of the community dont really care, because then the recognition itself means almost nothing. Its not a matter of female vs male athletes, its a matter of preference of sport among the community.
Anonymous • Sep 20, 2013 at 12:03 pm
I think this article is great! But in the end, I think it’s a person’s choice. The Senior Girls aren’t being forced to do this, so it’s evident that they enjoy it. As long as girl and coed sports are being recognized, it’s not sexist. I think Senior Guys is a great idea!
Anonymous • Sep 19, 2013 at 8:15 pm
People are missing the point of this article. It’s short, sweet, to the point, and brings up an issue that’s often “swept under the rug.” Well done.
Piper • Sep 19, 2013 at 6:18 pm
Thank you, thank you! Ths is an amazing article, and so true.
I don’t want to go pointing fingers here, but the posters aren’t the big issue. Baking cookies or decorating rooms isn’t the big issue. The big issue is that the administration seems to care more about football than any other sport. Sure, Dr. Carter gives a shout out to the cross country team, the volleyball team, whatever, when he has the microphone during pep rallies. But the pep rallies aren’t for cross country, volleyball, soccer, swimming, golf, or tennis! The pep rallies are held on Fridays when the football team has a game, not a Tuesday when the volleyball team has a match, or when the swim team has a meet. The football players sit on chairs in the center of the action. The band plays, hyline dances, cheerleaders … Cheer-lead? And everybody cheers. Everything you would see at a football game. How about we have a pep rally when we send cross country to state, or our musicians qualify for Allstate, or Latin Club goes to nationals? Westlake has so many amazing things going on, and we should celebrate our diverse accomplishments, not ignore them all to zone in on one sport.
Zach • Sep 20, 2013 at 5:38 pm
Why do you think that Football gets the most recognition? Or that they get the most funding? Or that the focus of the school is on football? It’s because of revenue! The football stadium seats around ten thousand people. Hypothetically speaking, if nobody pays for concessions(who’s proceeds go to other non-football extracurriculars), nine out of 10 people have to pay 8 dollars to get in. That is seventy two thousand dollars for one football game that gets sold out (presumably Lake Travis game). Even when it doesn’t sell out, normally around five to six thousand people show up each home game. So it averages to be around forty thousand dollars per game. Name the last time a female or coed sport had near that turnout. I dare you. The reason they do pep rallys on Fridays is not just football, but because that the administration can’t expect to throw random pep rallys into their teachers curriculum, which is already overcrowded with them taking five and six classes at a time. Friday is easily the most convenient time for a pep rally due to the fact that it’s a consistent day of the week to have a class interruption and that practically no learning actually happens on Fridays. The recognition of a sport or activity is not correlated to the relative ability of the group. If that were true, then the choir would get the most recognition, considering they’ve gotten all superiors since 19 tickety two. Recognition is not only due to amount of revenue, but also the amount of interest in a sport. Look at the NBA vs the WNBA. The girls in the WNBA have just as much fundamental skill as the NBA players, sometimes they’re better (defense especially). But why doesn’t the WNBA have as much hype as the NBA? Is it because us americans just are so sexist against women that we refuse to show them support? NO! Its because they don’t tomahawk the ball through the basket every other second, or have the high-flying alley-oops(how do you write that)! Same reason for football. To the majority of the people at Westlake, going out to the golf course or the tennis courts or the cheerleading gyms or the swimming pools is not an exciting way to spend their time. For them, Football is worth spending their time going to. That’s not to say that following those sports isn’t interesting, or that those athletes don’t spend an equal amount of time and effort for their sport, because we all know that they do spend countless hours perfecting what they do. I agree with Lauren. If the school agrees that there should be a male-equivalent of the “senior girls” etc. then they should set it up themselves, not have it forced upon them. It should be their decision, considering they are the reason why the founders of Westlake built the school, for them to learn, to build relationships with their classmates, and to build leadership skills. Let the students lead themselves and make their decisions. If anybody reads this whole thing, I give you full congratulations, considering that I probably ranted too long and I don’t even remember what I was talking about at the very beginning.
Anonymous • Sep 22, 2013 at 10:09 pm
Don’t misinterpret this article. Nowhere in there does it say anything about forcing the school to do anything. The article is merely there to suggest that there’s an imbalance and that there’s a solution to it. Please learn to read the words on the page, and not the words you want to see.
Eugene Miravete • Sep 24, 2013 at 2:19 pm
Amen zach, and the article explicitely suggest the ending of senior girls, and provides alternatives, such as having different sports teams support each other, the fact is, as zach pointed out, even with all that, nothing will (in the forseeable future) come even close to football with attendance topping several thousand fans a week. Anonymous, there is an imbalance, but it exist out of choice.
Sarah • Sep 19, 2013 at 6:13 pm
I really do think the Senior Girls are great! They have fun doing what they do, and being in that kind of organization really brings the seniors together! But there is definitely something wrong with the overshadowing of girl’s sports. If Westlake could show that same amount of support and energy for their girls, it could start a whole new tradition at Westlake. The girls kill their competition as well!
Anonymous • Sep 19, 2013 at 4:39 pm
Although I completely recognize that it is a choice to be a senior girl, the way the system is set up does reinforce traditional gender roles. There’s nothing wrong with supporting the guys playing various sports–“Senior Girls, Courtside Cuties, etc.” are fun traditions. However, there SHOULD be something similar set up for the girls (and co-ed sports). Even when our teams are successful, the most recognition we get is a short announcement on the Chap Re-cap. Senior Girls put a lot of time and effort into making “their boys” feel appreciated and supported, so it would be nice if the guys could do the same for us.
The article never said that the girls who are “Senior Girls” are supporting sexism. It said that the system is sexist, which it is (only because the guys don’t do the same for the girls). A group of guys should really just take initiative and start a system that gives back to their hard-working senior girls!
Eugene Miravete • Sep 24, 2013 at 2:07 pm
Frankly, you make a good point, and i dont necesarily disagree, however the act of getting boys to bake goods to give to their senior girls is something that requires a lot of initiative, frankly i have not seen that kind of innitiative anywhere in this school. So dont hold your breath until it happens.
Lauren Ross • Sep 19, 2013 at 3:02 pm
All of us girls that are senior girls and so on are not supporting sexism. We are being go getters and starting groups that support our male athletes. If you and your supporters think the girls are not being supported then you can get off your computer, and create male groups that make signs and support the girls teams.
Emily • Sep 19, 2013 at 1:29 pm
This is a really great piece about an important topic. Thank you for writing it!!
Zach • Sep 19, 2013 at 1:05 pm
Honestly, if you think the tradition of girls being senior girls etc for guys is sexist, it’s extremely disappointing in your knowledge of how things actually are. Those girls volunteer for those positions, and it’s not because their weak and feeble, but its because they want to be a part of the long standing tradition that is the senior girls. Also, there are signs that are for the wrestling team, the swimming team, the golf team, etc. You just don’t get them during football season for either a) they cant fit as sign up there or b) because that sport isn’t even in season yet. It has nothing to do with guy athletes being better then girl athletes. A lot of girls choose to be senior girls etc also because they want to impress their senior guy. They have full choice of how much they give their guy. I was a football player in 2012 and I got one sign the whole year. A certain golfer got 3 signs during golf season. If people wanted to put signs up for say, the swimming team, then they have full rights to do so. If you want to start a tradition that male students choose their “senior girl” to bake cookies for, decorate their room, etc, then there is absolutely nothing stopping you. And by the way, Title 9 is clearly taken effect, considering that girls play full court 5 on 5 basketball, and are given no barriers that are not given to the male athletes. I think that you and your editing team need to take a look from a perspective maybe other then your own before you start making broad assumptions about the mindset and attitude of not only a student body, but of a community as well.
Anonymous • Sep 19, 2013 at 7:19 pm
They’re not saying that Title 9 hasn’t taken effect, they’re saying that apparently, our society is stuck back then.
Anonymous • Sep 19, 2013 at 9:16 pm
There is no recognition for the girls soccer, tennis, or golf teams. Soccer was undefeated last year, while golf has won more state titles than football has.
Anonymous • Sep 19, 2013 at 9:58 pm
Staff editorials are supposed to represent the opinions of the staff, not necessarily the entire community or school.
Zach • Sep 20, 2013 at 5:38 pm
Look to long rant at bottom of page
Madi Goll • Sep 18, 2013 at 10:04 pm
This is fantastic.